BSD
The honor of our dear and very esteemed friend Rabbi Shmuel HaCohen NR
Raanana
Greetings
Regarding: Saying praise on Independence Day
His Honor was right that if once the debate on Hillel on Independence Day was between the Zionists and the anti-Zionists, these rejoice in it and praise it with praise, and these see it as a day of mourning, today when ideological Zionism weakened, the anti also weakened with it. , Among the Sephardim and even the so-called "Haredi" a new formula has been adopted saying the praise without blessing, and the compilers say it at the end of the prayer.
It is clear to anyone who understands that reciting a hymn without a blessing is not really there, and its repression at the end of the prayer is almost a disgrace and contempt, contrary to the previous ruling of most Sephardic rabbis who were Zionist and proud. Also on Jerusalem Day, and said the praise with blessing and kindness, as the testimonies of many Moroccan sages, and as the Geri Mashash wrote in the Treasure of Letters, but under the influence of Rabbi Ovadia Yosef, whose greatness in the Torah and his influence on the Sephardic world is indisputable, On the praise [Responsa Yavie says H.O. or C. M.A. letter A, and H.I. Most of the rabbis of the Land of Israel [RL according to the determination of the Chief Rabbinate Council] used to greet Hillel on Independence Day and he writes there in these words:Renewed Do not greet…
Although I have already written in the introduction to the Book of Independence in places that used to bless according to the rabbis of Israel will continue to bless and there is nothing after the custom "but the followers of the Ga'a Yosef say that whoever blesses on Hillel on Independence Day After all, many of our Sephardic and Western rabbis have ruled that this renewal of halakhah should be blessed by itself against a broad consensus of rabbis who used to bless! (In the Rabbinical Council convened by Rabbi Goren on the subject of a discussion on Hillel on Independence Day, the Ga'a Yosef was deliberately absent from the discussion.
And the decision of the Chief Rabbinate to say Hallel Bracha has remained in place to this day) The halakhic and social dictatorship he spread among the Sephardim that was sometimes expressed by force among his followers Who behaved differently.
There is a long answer from Rabbi David Shlosha on the matter [Responsa Hemda Genoza Kha'a Question 21] who discusses the words of the arbitrators well and proves that praise should be congratulated on Independence Day, and the praise of Independence Day should not be diminished by praise It is ignored as if it did not exist and is an important Sephardic jurist of the greatest disciples of Rabbi Rashlat in Tzemach Uziel and among the few Sephardic jurists in our generation who discusses with the rulings of the Ga'a Yosef in depth and represents the traditional Sephardic ruling from generation to generation, and it is no secret that Rabbi Ovadia Yosef did not tolerate him, and anyone who had an opinion that was too independent and did not bow down before him, like the genius Rachad Halevi, there is no doubt that Rabbi Ovadia Yosef was a great arbiter and full of rights who worked hard for the people of Israel.
But the truth must be told that he destroyed the Spanish and especially the diverse and diverse Moroccan tradition and replaced it with a ridiculous imitation of non-Zionist "Sephardic-ultra-Orthodox" that increasingly became jealous and closed, sometimes he wanted to consider the zealots, but over time also followed their ideology Educated in the anti-Zionist yeshivas have put their misguided opinions everywhere and already today there are Sephardic-ultra-Orthodox quorums that even hail without blessing do not say on Independence Day and even say confession as usual.
I remember about forty years ago when I came to serve as a young rabbi in a chain session of Hapoel Mizrahi, and everyone there was public and were Zionists with crocheted kippahs, and I came from a chair of mercy who would say a plea on Independence Day, (and already in my election ) I immediately informed them that they would continue their custom of solemn prayer and saying a hymn of blessing, and I was the cantor in a proper singing and melody to the class, and one of the warm-hearted Teshuvahs (this is their way) tweeted against me, that a blessing should not be blessed! And I told him to be silent and showed him the words of the responsa of the LKT that in the blessings of praise there is no law of blessing to cancel at all, [the responsa of the LKT H. Its meaning is only from Durban, and instead of practicing there is no other custom, and leave them to Israel, and now saying Hallel on the Independence Day is not just a dry halakhic discussion but a statement and thought that we believe Gd runs the world as He wills, and the State of Israel was established as our redemption The postcards, on the noses of all kinds of anti-Zionists, and we continue in this both the tradition of the ruling and what our ancestors and rabbis have always done.
Writer and seal welcome
By Haim Amsalem