BSD
Question by the rabbi of the Spanish communities in the city of Seattle Washington
Here are the days of Tishrei coming and going, and this year because of the old corona plague, and those at risk from the age of sixty-five and up will avoid going to prayer in the synagogue where there are many crowds, but since there are limits of distance between one and the other Worshipers, as well as women, only a minority will be able to pray in the synagogue, and here one of the worshipers owns a company that provides a "video conferencing" service, ie service for direct video calls, and is willing to install screens in all synagogue houses and other synagogue halls. Direct, and so all the prayers will be heard, and there will be a great acquittal of the many.
Doubts that arise:
A- Is it allowed to use such a service on a good day and Saturday?
B-Is there a difference between a good day and a Sabbath for that matter,
C- Will the hearers answer Kaddish and Kadusha ?, for hearing the prayer from the synagogue hall?
D. Is it considered a public prayer for them? Is this allowed on Yom Kippur as well? And did they get out of it by blowing the shofar?
Answer:
Here is the first provider, regarding the use of this technology that stays on from the day before Yom Tov and Yom Kippur, it must be said simply that this is allowed because everything is done on the eve of the holiday, Israel, and a mountain was forced upon them like a tub by the strict who are mostly Ashkenazi sages who are influential and dictate the halakhic agenda, and went terrified of the mitigators, and almost idle, and saying so in public to the stranger will be considered And on the eve of a good day, and even on a good day itself it was perfectly permissible for the custom of North Africa and other places, for this thing is necessary and to speak a mitzvah, and even "saying to a Gentile to return" for many needs, and to speak a mitzvah and so on. .
As for the second supplier, as explained above that everything is directed and done on the eve of Yom Tov, then even on Shabbat there is no actual prohibition and prohibition, just like the Shabbat clock installed to turn on and off or a Shabbat elevator going up and down automatically without human contact, allowed and stripped the balance, The inspector watches and directs the camera and also makes sure that to prevent or even fix some technical fault, what about that? After all, it is just like a Shabbat gentile who used to use it for every need on Shabbat itself in all sorts of things, and this is customary to allow, especially when it comes to electricity, which is easier to ban on such a good day.
And as for the third doubt, if the hearers answer Kaddish and Kaddisha, it is simply that since there are ten in one place and they say Kaddish and Kadusha legally, it is the law that the hearers directly and as allowed in the Great Sea Responsa sign 29 to hear through the radio and phone. It is obligatory for all the hearers to come out even with the blowing of the shofar and the scroll, especially with other commandments that depend on voice and speech. Similarly, it ruled in the Water of Life Responsa (Chab. Similarly, Rabbi Feinstein also wrote about the obligatory departure of hearing the Megillah through the radio, the responsa of the Epistles of Moses (Chab. Y., and H.G. D. H.G. (C.N.D.) in a remark, which brought some great in such an opinion, and see the answer I have written more extensively on the matter of going out by duty through the zoom, doctrine of life (mark d), and if so all those mitigating arbitrators should be relied upon.
And as for the fourth doubt if one goes out of duty, here from what we have stripped the third doubt also goes out the fourth, that the hearers have gone out of their duty as a prayer in the real public.
And as for the fifth doubt, in the matter of Yom Kippur, there is no difference in all doubts and what is allowed because everything is done spontaneously without human intervention and contact, and oh just like the shining electricity lit on the west of Yom Kippur and Shabbat.
And regarding the sixth doubt in the law of blowing the shofar, here is the great rabbi I brought above in the third doubt, not that I am between the shofar and the scroll and in both the hearer came out, and indeed regarding the shofar In the Mishnah (p. 27b), the one who blows into the pit and the echo if the sound of the shofar heard came out and if the sound of the syllable did not come out, and stopped in the Shulchan Aruch The shofar is really not a syllable, and simple, but sometimes the listener does not hear completely at the same time because there is little time for the sound waves to pass and it is called "delay", however it is little time and less than the rate of saying to speech On you Rabbi and Mori ", and such a gift is not considered detached from the source of her utterance and in everything Kaimlan" while speaking as a feeble speech ", see Bava Kama (p. 3b).
And so from all of them it seems to me that they can install in their community this year precisely because many need such a system of video conferencing for the purpose of prayers and blowing the shofar.
As above to answer in the reaper of the saying and give to the wise and the wise more
Regards by Haim Amsalem, Tu B'Av 5764